Lemme start by sharing my views.
1.> PES 2009
+ Much better graphics than FIFA for sure [Very Realistic]
+ Stadiums and Crowd details are awesome
+ Dynamic rotationg adboards.
+ Better gameplay than Fifa.
+ Crosses are awesome.
+ Liked the commentary.
+ Champions League.
+ Difficult to score goals in higher difficulties.
+ Awesome Replays.
- Confusing menus [i hate it always , too much to choose]
- Only Few Stadiums and still pseudo team names.
2.> FIFA 09
+ Play with Messi he scores goals from all angles.
[My first manager mode purchase , he was damn difficult to purchase ]
+ Play using Classic 11 this team rocks like hell and enjoyed playing with it the most , i wud say they are unbeatable.
[but you will have to unlock it first , Must Try]
+ Manager Mode , love it.
+ Better Faces and other character details than last year.
+ Loads of Tricks [ but i hardly use it] [Different for different players]
+ Real player movements try ronaldo and dinho
- Same old repetitive commentary but many bugs have been fixed this year.
Gamplay : PES 2009 wins hands down.hyeah:
Manager Mode and List of Teams and Stadiums : FIFA 09 :hap2:
These are my views you may have a different opinion.